PlanGenius Awards 2026

Selection process and scoring

Every entrant goes through the same steps and is scored out of 100 on five published criteria.

PlanGenius Awards 2026 seal

The process, step by step

  1. December 7, 2026 to January 17, 2027

    Reader survey

    Open to everyone. One response per verified email. A provider is scored on the survey only after 100 verified responses.

  2. December 14, 2026 to January 15, 2027

    Provider data window

    Providers can submit plan details and flag errors. We use public sources whether or not a provider responds.

  3. By December 18, 2026

    Rules are published

    Categories, criteria, weights and dates are final and public before any scoring starts.

  4. January 11, 2027

    Price snapshot

    We record checkout prices across sample postal codes and save screenshots as evidence.

  5. January 18 to January 26, 2027

    Scoring

    Two scorers score every entrant independently. Differences are discussed and reconciled, and both original scores and the final score are archived.

  6. January 27 to January 29, 2027

    Independent review

    Reviewers outside PlanGenius confirm we followed this method. They can challenge a score. They cannot add or swap a winner.

  7. February 1, 2027

    Winners are notified under embargo

    Scores are locked and timestamped before any commercial conversation begins. Providers see their own scorecard and can point out factual errors.

  8. February 9, 2027

    Winners are announced

    Each category names a winner, a runner-up and up to two finalists.

How a score is built

Each criterion is scored from 0 to 10 using a written rubric. Each score is multiplied by that criterion's weight, and the results are added up to give a total out of 100. The default weights are:

Price and value
30%
Terms and transparency
20%
Network performance
20%
Customer experience
20%
Features and flexibility
10%

Some awards put more weight on what they are about, so there are five weight sets:

Criterion Default Value awards Best Customer Service Most Transparent Pricing Internet Reliability
Price and value305015150
Terms and transparency2020106010
Network performance200101060
Customer experience2015601030
Features and flexibility1015550
Total100100100100100

Which weights apply to which award

Weight setAwards
Value awardsBest Value Home Internet, Best Value Mobile Plan, Best Internet for Students, Best Plan for Students, Best Family Plan
Best Customer ServiceBest Customer Service
Most Transparent PricingMost Transparent Pricing
Internet ReliabilityBest Internet Reliability and Uptime
DefaultAll other awards

Survey fairness rules

  • A provider needs at least 100 verified responses to be scored on the survey. Below that, we use complaint data alone and mark the survey as "not scored".
  • One response per verified email address.
  • We limit how much weight any one provider's responses can carry, so a provider cannot win by rallying its own customers.
  • We publish response counts for every provider.

If scores are tied

  1. The higher customer experience score wins.
  2. If still tied, the higher terms and transparency score wins.
  3. If still tied, the entrants are named co-winners.

Corrections, appeals and revocation

  • Factual corrections. Providers can dispute factual errors within 14 days of being notified. Errors found before the announcement are fixed before it. Errors found later are corrected on the page and logged.
  • Opinions and weights. The criteria and weights are published in advance, so they are not open to appeal.
  • Revocation. An award can be withdrawn after a finding of misleading advertising or serious regulator action. Any badge is then switched off and the reason is published.

For the full set of independence rules, see integrity and disclosure. For data sources and definitions, see the methodology.

Disclosure: PlanGenius earns a commission when you sign up with some providers through links on this site, and some providers pay for advertising or featured listings. None of this affects who is considered or who wins. Read our integrity rules and full disclosure.